Catherine, an unusual puzzle/interactive fiction game that puts you in the position of a man who is cheating on his girlfriend, has a large number of achievements and trophies that can only be gained by performing specific actions throughout the entire game from beginning to end.
Your progress tends to carry between saves such as your level on Rapunzel, accessed in the bar. This means you don't have to complete Rapunzel all in one game and can keep coming back to it through multiple saves. Other things which carry between saves include trophies obtained, explained in further detail below, and the number of endings you've unlocked which effects things like pictures from the girls.
There are 11 missable achievements/trophies. These ones require specific actions throughout the game where, if one action is missed, the entire achievement/trophy will be forfeited.This guide will cover all actions required to obtain all of them. All missable achievements are listed below.
 | Read All About It! | Get Justin Out Of His Jam | 10G | Bronze Trophy |
 | A New Look | Help Todd Out Of His Trouble | 10G | Bronze Trophy |
 | Mother Inferior | Help Archie Work Through His Quandary | 10G | Bronze Trophy |
 | Love Is Patient, Love Is Kind | Resolve Daniel's Dilemma | 10G | Bronze Trophy |
 | One Last Case | Help Morgan Clean Up His Mess | 10G | Bronze Trophy |
 | Everyday Hero | Help Everybody Out Of Their Predicaments | 50G | Silver Trophy |
 | Sake Sensei | Listen to all the sake sound bites | 10G | Bronze Trophy |
 | Beer Baron | Listen to all the beer factoids | 10G | Bronze Trophy |
 | Whisky Wiseman | Listen to all the whisky minutiae | 10G | Bronze Trophy |
 | Cocktail Connoisseur | Listen to all the cocktail trivia | 10G | Bronze Trophy |
 | Text Junkie | Reply to 20 text messages by the end of the final day | 20G | Bronze Trophy |
Several achievements/trophies require you to view the eight different endings and in order to obtain all of these you need to play the last segment of the game multiple times.
Each individual ending has its own individual achievement and, after unlocking all eight seperate achievements/trophies, you should get a ninth; 'Dreams Come True' worth 100G or a Gold Trophy.
In order to view these endings you need to obtain maximum chaos karma, maximum law karma and then a neutral karma which will require different playthroughs as karma is built up over the course of the game. The easiest way of gaining law/chaos karma points is through answering mail in the game in specific ways as well as choosing particular responses in the confessionals after each landing. Below I have broken down each mail you receive and which replies you should pick to receive the desired result of a maximum karma or neutral response. When detailing responses or answers that you must pick from all Chaos karma responses are red whilst Law karma responses are blue, answers which have no effect on karma will be simply grey.
Note: By completing the game once with gold trophies (in either Normal or Hard) on any of the stages, those same stages will be able to be skipped entirely during further playthroughs. This is an easy way to unlock additional endings as it means you only have to play through the days, not the nights, of the game and earn your desired Karma rating.
Example: I beat the game on Normal but had started a Hard difficulty playthrough and obtained gold trophies on Night 1 and Night 2. By starting a new playthrough in Hard I could skip Night 1 and 2 entirely (by pausing the game and selecting skip) despite having not completed the game in Hard difficulty.
Confessionals:
Whilst I have listed some of the known questions that you may receive for each night of the game the questions are mostly random and some which you don't receive early on in the game you may receive at later stages. If you don't see a question listed on one of the specific night's confessional you may find it in another confessional list at a different part of the guide.
Night 1: Underground Cemetery
Nothing can be done during Night 1 that affects any achivements or the story in general.
Day 1: The Stray Sheep Bar
Start by answering Katherine's mail 'Checking in' before saving your game, otherwise you may not get a second mail.
Reply: ‘Does it bother you?’ (+1 law point) then ‘I worry about it too sometimes' (+0.5 law points), 'Maybe we should talk about this' (+1 law point) then finally 'Drive home safe, okay?' (+1 law point) for the maximum law response (3.5 law points)
Reply: ‘Does it bother you?’ (+1 law point), 'Is this some kind of test?' (+0.5 chaos points), 'I think we're ok as we are.' (no change), 'It'll just stress you out more.' (+0.5 chaos points), 'Let's catch a movie sometime. See ya!' (no change). for a neutral response (no change).
Reply: ‘Sorry can't think right now’ (+1.5 chaos points), ‘it's important to be comfortable in life’(+1 chaos point), 'I'm pretty tired right now' (+1 chaos point) then finally 'So...yeah...' (+1 chaos point) for a maximum chaos response. (4.5 chaos points)
If you obtain at least three law points during this text Katherine will respond with the text 'Wait a second...', be sure to do this immediately and not save first otherwise you will not receive this second one.
Reply:‘Guilty as charged.' (+1 law point) then ‘I'll make sure I don't drink enough to get a hangover' (no change) then finally 'Good night, Katherine' (+0.5 law points) for the maximum law response (1.5 law points)
Reply:'No I'm not there' (+0.5 chaos points), 'I don't need that place.' 'Good night, Katherine' (+0.5 law points) for a neutral response (no change).
Reply: ‘You don't own me’ (+1.5 chaos points), ‘Sometimes a man needs a drink, you know?’(+1 chaos point), then 'L8r' (+0.5 chaos points) for a maximum chaos response. (3 chaos points)
If you reply with at least 1 law point during this mail then Katherine will call you. Reply with 'I don't mind' during the phonecall for additional law points.
Night 2: Prison of Despair
Landing 1:
Talk to every sheep here, if when sheep do not have conversation choices you still need to talk to them for the 'Everyday Hero' achievement/trophy.
Talk to the sheep sittong on the pew and when they say, 'Aaahhh I don't want to die!' pick 'Calm down' ('Everyday Hero') this also gives law points.
Talk to the sheep with regent hair and pick: 'Yes, tell me!' then 'I didn't know...' ('A New Look' Achievement/Trophy)
Landing 2:
Again, talk to every sheep here.
Talk to the sheep standing to the right on the edge and when they say, 'News flash: FUCK YOU! I need to make sure I survive!' pick 'That's not right!' ('Everyday Hero')
Talk to the sheep with regent hair and pick: 'Teach me something else' then 'No...' ('A New Look' Achievement/Trophy)
Potential confessional questions:
Question | Law answer | Chaos answer |
Does life begin or end at marriage? | It begins | It ends |
| Do you prefer being in quiet or loud places? | I like it quiet | Bring in the noise! |
Which is a better life? | Long and dull | Short and full |
Is it ok to live with your partner without ever intending to marry them? | Not a chance | Yes indeed |
| Do you prefer to stand out from the crowd or fit in? | Fit in | Stand out |
Which makes you more nervous? | Being alone | Being with others |
Prefer an older or younger partner? | Older | Younger |
Does your job always come first? | No | Yes |
Is romance annoying? | I wuv it! | I hate it |
Do you like the words 'world domination'? | This is stupid! | Yessssss |
| You must kiss one of these. Choose. | A cephelopod-like alien | A beautiful corpse |
Day 2: The Stray Sheep Bar.
Drink all 4 alcohols: Cocktail, Beer, Whisky and Sake. (Cocktail Connoisseur, Beer Baron, Whisky Wiseman and Sake Sensei Achievements/Trophies.)
Watch extra scenes with Erica after the first drink.
Talk to Orlando and pick 'Don't say that...' for law points or 'That's only if I don't get caught' for chaos points.
Talk to Jonny
Talk to Toby twice
Receive mail 'Congratulations!'
Talk to Jonny
Talk to Orlando
Answer mail 'Are you are SS again?' from Katherine.
Reply: 'Sorry I wasn't home' (+0.5 law points), 'What did you want to talk about?' (+0.5 law points), 'I think I know what you're gonna tell me...'(+1 law point), '...I understand (+1.5 law points), 'Good night, Katherine' (+0.5 law points)
Reply: 'Sorry I wasn't home' (+0.5 law points), 'We'll talk tomorrow' (+0.5 chaos points), 'I bet you're tired too' (+0.5 chaos points), 'Bye' (no change) for a neutral response (no change).
Reply: ‘Don't touch my stuff’ (+1 chaos point), ‘Sorry I'm too tired to talk right now’(+1 chaos point), then 'Man, I'm sleepy...' (+1 chaos point) for a maximum chaos response. (3 chaos points)
If you reply with at least 1.5 law points during this text then Katherine will respond with another text entitled, 'About tomorrow'
Talk to Erica three times
Talk to Boss and answer with 'I'm telling the truth' for law points or 'I actually don't remember' for chaos points.
Receive the text 'Is this reaching you' from Catherine, answer with:
Reply: 'Who is this?' (no change) then 'Do I know you?(+1 law point),' for the maximum law response (+1 law point)
Reply: 'Who is this?'(no change) then 'Don't message me again' (+0.5 law points). for the most neutral response (no change)
Reply: 'This is Vincent' (+1 chaos point) then 'PIX NAO PLZ!' (+2 chaos points) for the maximum chaos response (+3 chaos points)
If you obtain at least 2 chaos points Catherine will respond with the text 'YAY' whereas if you ignore this text and don't reply she will respond with the text 'R U getting these'.
After you've replied or ignored Catherine, talk to Boss again.
Receive mail 'The Passage of Time' and 'About tomorrow' if you met the requirement in Katherine's earlier message.
Reply: 'Huh, what happened?' (+1 law point), 'Sounds important I'll definitely be there' (+1 law point), 'Go easy on yourself, okay?' (+1 law point) then 'Well, goodnight, Katherine (+0.5 law points),' for the maximum law response (+3.5 law points)
Reply: 'Okay I'll try to make it' (no change) then 'See you tomorrow then' (no change). for the most neutral response (no change)
Reply: 'Well, I'll go if I can' (+0.5 chaos points) then 'Bye' (+0.5 chaos points) for the maximum chaos response (+1 chaos point)
If you reply with at least 1.5 law points then Katherine will now call you. There's no Karma choices here.
Talk to Lindsey and Martha sitting down, then standing up.
Talk to Todd, Archie and Justin standing up then sit down and talk to them. Reply with 'Maybe...' for both conversations ('Mother Inferior', 'Read all about it!', 'A New Look' and 'Everyday Hero')
Stand up and talk to Todd/Archie and Justin again
Sit back down at the booth with Orlando, Jonny and Toby. Orlando will go to the bathroom.
After the conversation, talk to Orlando.
Talk to Jonny.
Receive either 'YAY' or 'R U getting these' from Catherine depending on how you answered earlier.
Reply to 'R U getting these' with either:
Reply: 'Uh... Who are you?'(+0.5 law points) then 'Can I have your name?' for the maximum law response (+1.5 law points)
Reply: 'Uh... Who are you?' (+0.5 law points) then 'You're bothering me.' (+0.5 law points) OR 'I got your message.' (+1 chaos point) then 'Don't talk to me' (no change) for the most neutral response of either +1 chaos point or +1 law point there's no way of getting no change.
Reply: 'I got your message.' (+1 chaos point) then 'What do you want?' (+1 chaos point) for the maximum chaos response. (+2 chaos point)
If you respond with at least 2 chaos points with this text then Catherine will respond with 'YAY'.
After the text, talk to Toby
Talk to Boss
Receive the 'YAY' message if you responded positively to the last one.
Reply: 'Don't send me this stuff!' (+0.5 law points), 'Aren't you going to get in trouble if someone see's that?' (+0.5 law points), then finally 'I'm tired. Bye' for the maximum law response.
Reply: 'That's it?' (no change) then 'Seeya' (no change) for the most neutral response (no change).
Reply: 'Wow, nice' (+1 chaos point) then 'Not quite revealing everything makes it even better...' (+1.5 chaos points) for the maximum chaos response (+2.5 chaos points).
Finish up the night however you want; wash your face in the bathroom, watch TV, save your game and play Rapunzel.
Talk to Boss to advance time until Catherine arrives, talk to her twice then leave.
Night 3: Torture Chamber
Landing 1:
Talk to every sheep on the landing
Talk to the sheep with glasses and pick 'I'll join you' ('Read all about it!' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to the sheep with regent hair and pick: 'Please tell me' ('A New Look' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to the sheep with sunglasses and pick: 'I'm clueless, too!' ('Love is patient, Love is kind' Achievement/Trophy)
Landing 2:
Talk to every sheep here
Talk to the sheep and pick 'What do you mean, terrible?' ('Everyday Hero' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to the sheep with glasses and pick 'I'll join you' ('Read all about it!' Achievement/Trophy)
Potential confessional questions:
Question | Law answer | Chaos answer |
Who would be responsible if you cheated? | It'd be my fault | The person I cheat with |
| Are you a pervert? | I don't think so | No use denying it |
Which is more like "paradise"? | A beautiful countryside | Somewhere I can get a drink |
Do you talk back to the TV? | No way! | Maybe... |
| Are all men stupid? | Not all men... | That's right |
What do you think of actors in sex scenes? | It's just a job | Lucky! |
Have you ever gotten a bloody nose from excitement? | No... | Well... |
Which is more cheating? | An emotional tryst | A physical fling |
Is popping bubble wrap fun? | What a waste! | Hell yes! |
Which of the following would you bring to a deserted island? | A compass | A piano |
| You must kiss one of these. Choose. | A cephelopod-like alien | A beautiful corpse |
| Could you have sex with an attractive ghost? | No ghosts, please | I'm not picky |
| Has being embarrassed ever turned you on? | No! | Yes. |
Can money buy you love? | No. | Yes. |
| You find your lover's kink horrifyingly unsexy. What do you do? | I'll try anything once. | The relationship is over. |
Do you have to carefully choose which underwear to wear each day? | Not really | Yes |
| What are your thoughts on underpants? | You wear it... under your pants. | It can go anywhere |
Day 3: The Stray Sheep Bar.
Drink all 4 alcohols: Cocktail, Beer, Whisky and Sake. (Cocktail Connoisseur, Beer Baron, Whisky Wiseman and Sake Sensei Achievements/Trophies.)
Talk to Lindsey and Martha and reply with 'I write them down' for a law response or 'I remember it' for a chaos response. Talk to them again whilst standing.
Talk to Orlando and pick 'I know... but' for a law response or 'W-wait a minute' for a chaos response.
Talk to Jonny and pick 'Well I need some sort of direction' for a law response or 'That's true' for a chaos response.
Receive mail 'Congratulations'
Talk to Toby twice until Jonny goes to the bathroom, watch the scene.
Receive and answer mail from Katherine 'Are you drinking?'
Reply: 'Sorry...' (+0.5 law points), 'But it's important to be with my friends too' (+0.5 law points) then 'Why, what's going on? Is there something wrong?' (+0.5 law points) for the maximum law response (1.5 law points)
Reply:'Sorry...' (+0.5 law points),'Can't I at least hang out with my friends?' (+0.5 chaos points) then 'Stop assuming the worst about me.' (no change) for the most neutral response of (no change)
Reply: 'I'll do what I feel like' (+1 chaos point), 'I don't need you on my back every second' (+1 chaos point) then 'I'll talk to you later' (no change) for the maximum chaos response (2 chaos points)
If you obtain the maximum law response then Katherine will reply with the text 'I'm sorry.'
Talk to Orlando
Talk to Jonny
Receive and answer a text from Catherine entitled 'Hey!'
Reply: 'Sorry I'm still at work' (no change) then 'Sorry, gotta run' (no change) then 'Bye' (+0.5 law points) for the maximum law response (0.5 law points)
Reply: 'Sorry I'm still at work' (no change) then 'Sorry, gotta run' (no change), then either 'Bye' (+0.5 law points) or 'Good night, Catherine' (+0.5 chaos points) for the most neutral response available.
Reply: 'Yeah, I'm done (+1 chaos point), 'I can't see you today, though, I'm busy (no change) then 'I'll text you again later' (+1 chaos point) for the maximum chaos response (2 chaos points)
If you obtain at least 1.5 chaos points Catherine will respond with 'Okies' whereas if you respond with at least 0.5 law points then she will respond with 'Oh...'
Talk to Erica twice
Talk to Daniel and Anna whilst standing
Sit down and talk to Daniel and Anna again, make sure you pick 'I think so, too...' ('Love is patient, love is kind' achievement/trophy)
Receive mail 'Okies' or 'Oh...' from Catherine depending on how you responded to 'Hey!'
In response to 'Okies':
Reply: 'Don't send me pictures!' (+0.5 law points), 'You can't just send me stuff like this without any warning' (+0.5 law points), then 'Let's stop right here' (+0.5 law points) for the maximum law response (1.5 law points)
Reply: 'Hehehe? Do I want to know?' (no change) then 'What are you planning...?' (no change) for the most neutral response (no change)
Reply: 'Hehehe? Do I want to know?' (no change), 'What have you got in mind? (+1 chaos point) then 'Heh heh' (+1 chaos point) for the maximum chaos response (2 chaos points)
In response to 'Oh...':
Reply: For the maximum law response, just don't reply to the text
Reply: 'Good' (no change) then 'Well, good night' (+0.5 chaos points) for the most neutral reply (+0.5 chaos points) alternatively, just don't reply.
Reply: 'Thanks' (+0.5 chaos points), 'It's not like we're never going to see each other again...' (+1 chaos point) then 'Good night, Catherine. (+1 chaos point) for the maximum law response (2.5 chaos points)
Talk to Boss
Stand up and talk to Daniel and Anna again
Talk to Justin standing up
Answer a phone call from Catherine if you responded positively to 'Okies'
Receive and answer mail 'I'm sorry' from Katherine if you responded positively to 'Are you drinking?'
Reply: 'I'm sorry too' (+0.5 law points), 'You don't have to apologize' (+0.5 law points), 'I'll definitely think about' (+0.5 law points) then finally, 'Well good night' (no change) for the maximum law response (1.5 law points)
Reply: 'I know' (no change), 'Don't worry about it' (+0.5 law points), 'Bye' (+0.5 chaos points) for the most neutral response (no change)
Reply: 'I know' (no change), 'I'll get around to it' (+1 chaos point) then, 'Bye' (+0.5 chaos points) for the maximum chaos response (1.5 chaos points)
If you obtain the maximum law response you will receive a phone call from Katherine.
Talk to Morgan whilst sat down, then once again standing up ('One Last Case' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to Erica
Sit down and talk to Justin then pick 'Men, of course' ('Read all about it!' Achievement/Trophy)
Stand up and talk to Justin again
Talk to Todd and Archie whilst standing
Talk to Jonny, Orlando and Toby
Talk to Erica twice
Sit down and talk to Todd and Archie and pick 'Lots of money' ('A New Look' and 'Mother Inferior' Achievements/Trophies)
Talk to Boss twice
Talk to Catherine when she arrives and pick 'That's not what grown ups do' for a law response or 'That's true' for a chaos response
Night 4: Inquisition
Landing 1:
Speak with every sheep on the landing
Talk to the sheep in the police hat and pick: 'I think so...' ('One Last Case' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to the sheep with the long-haired sheep and pick: 'Join the conversation' ('Mother Inferior' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to the sheep and pick 'Come on, get a hold of yourself!' ('Everyday Hero Achievement/Trophy)
Day 4: The Stray Sheep Bar.
Drink all 4 alcohols: Cocktail, Beer, Whisky and Sake. (Cocktail Connoisseur, Beer Baron, Whisky Wiseman and Sake Sensei Achievements/Trophies.)
Watch a scene with Erica when she comes over.
Talk to Lindsey and Martha sitting down to be asked: “Would you rather watch baseball/golf at home?” Pick golf for chaos and baseball for law.
Talk to Lindsey and Martha standing up.
Talk to the couple by the arcade machine twice.
Talk to Morgan sitting down then standing up. ('One Last Case' Achievement/Trophy)
Receive four mail, none of which you can reply it.
Talk to Justin sitting down. ('Read all about it!' Achievement/Trophy)
Reply to the mail from Catherine: ‘Heyyy’
Reply: ‘Why do you care’ (+0.5 law points) then ‘I can’t see you today' (+0.5 law points) for the maximum law response (1 law point)
Reply: ‘Why do you care’ (+0.5 law points) ‘Grownups have to work for a living’ (+0.5 chaos points) and ‘we’ll talk later’ (no change) for a neutral response.
Reply: ‘I’m drinking with friends’ (+1 chaos point) and ‘we’ll talk later’ (no change) for a maximum chaos response. (1 chaos point)
If you reply with a chaos response you’ll receive mail from Catherine titled ‘You meanie!’
Talk with Jonny at the bar.
Talk to Justin standing up.
Reply to the mail ‘About this morning’ from Katherine.
Reply: ‘I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to chase you away’ (+0.5 law points), ‘I wanted to protect you…’ (+0.5 law points), ‘I want to talk to you too’ (+1 law point), ‘I really care about you’ (+1 law point) and finally, ‘Good night Katherine’ (+0.5 law points) for the maximum law response (3.5 law points)
Reply: ‘I can't get that stink out of my room…’ (no change) ‘Come see me another time’(no change) ‘We can talk about the details the next time we see each other’ (+0.5 chaos points) then finally ‘Well, good night, Katherine’ (+0.5 law points) for a neutral response (no change)
Reply: ‘It’s okay’ (+1 chaos point) ‘But you did surprise me, too’ (+1 chaos point) and ‘actually I’m too tired to talk, so I’ll see you later’ (+1 chaos point) for the maximum chaos response (3 chaos points)
If you ignore the mail or reply with at least 2 law points Katherine will send another mail entitled ‘I…’
Talk with Jonny at the bar again.
Talk to Erica.
Talk with Daniel and choose the 'Forget about it' option for the achievement. You can otherwise pick 'It was never a competition' for chaos points and no achievement. ('Love is patient, Love is kind' Achievement/Trophy)
After the conversation, talk to Daniel standing up.
Reply to the mail‘You meanie!’ if you met the above requirements.
Reply: 'Don't call me' (+0.5 law points) then 'I mean it, stop calling me' (+1 law point) for the maximum law response (1.5 law points)
Reply: 'You're so persistent...' (no change) then 'We've got nothing to talk about' (no change) for the most neutral response.
Reply: 'You're so persistent...' (no change) then 'I've got to run, no time to talk.' (+1 chaos point) for the maximum chaos response (1 chaos point)
If you reply with at least 1 chaos point during this mail Catherine will phone you. If you answer it, you'll receive +1 chaos points. If you instead reply with at least 0.5 law points then you'll receive the mail 'Re:Re:You meanie!'
Talk to Boss.
Talk to Erica.
Talk to Archie and reply with 'Of course' to both questions he asks you ('Mother Inferior' Achievement/Trophy)
Reply to the mail 'Re:Re:You meanie!' from Catherine if you met the above conditions.
Reply: 'It's not like you have anything interesting to say' then 'Bye' for a law or neutral response, there is no change here.
Reply: 'Next time, ok?' (+0.5 chaos points) then 'Good night' (+0.5 chaos points) for the maximum chaos response (1 chaos point)
Reply to the mail 'I...' from Katherine if you met the above conditions.
Reply: 'Yeah, I'm sorry about that' (+0.5 law points), 'I need to make sure I'm ready emotionally.' (+0.5 law points) then 'Let's get together and talk things out soon.'
(+1 law point) for the maximum law response (2 law points)
Reply: 'Stop worrying so much' (+0.5 chaos points), 'I really care about you' (+0.5 law points) then 'See ya' (no change) for the most neutral response.
Reply: 'Stop worrying so much' (+0.5 chaos points), 'I'm tired...' (+0.5 chaos points) then 'Don't drink too much. It's not that good for you. Take it from me.' (+0.5 chaos points) for the maximum chaos response (1.5 chaos points)
If you reply with at least 1 law point Katherine will call you. If you choose to ignore it you will receive +1 chaos points.
Stand up and talk to Archie.
Talk to Erica.
Talk to Boss twice.
Receive mail 'Your fellow customers...'
Finish up the day however you like, Catherine won't be along tonight. Wash your face in the bathroom, maybe check out that mail from Catherine or play some Rapunzel.
Night 5: Quadrangle.
Landing 1:
Talk to every sheep here.
Talk to the sheep with glasses and pick: 'Teach me a technique!' ('Read all about it!' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to the sheep with regent hair and pick: 'The pregnancy was a lie?' ('A New Look' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to the sheep with sunglasses and pick: 'By the way, there's this technique...' ('Love is patient, Love is kind' Achievement/Trophy)
Landing 2:
Again, talk to every sheep here.
Talk to the sheep with regent hair and pick: 'That's your Dad's fault!' ('A New Look' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to the sheep with sunglasses and pick: 'I'll find a way for both of us.' ('Love is patient, Love is kind' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to the sheep in the police hat and pick: 'Let's work together.' ('One Last Case' Achievement/Trophy)
Day 5: The Stray Sheep bar.
Drink all four alcoholic drinks; Cocktail, Beer, Whisky, Sake. (Cocktail Connoisseur, Beer Baron, Whisky Wiseman and Sake Sensei Achievements.)
Watch an extra scene with Erica
Talk to Jonny twice, pick 'Who knows what's happening' for chaos points and 'I believe in her' for law points then 'I never give up' for law points or 'I always quit in the middle' for chaos points.
Talk to Orlando twice
Receive the mail 'Congratulations'
Talk to Archie ('Mother Inferior' and 'A New Look' Achievements/Trophies)
Reply to the two mails 'Eat your cake' and 'Some good medicine'
Reply to 'Eat your cake' from Katherine with:
Reply: 'Sorry, I've been busy, too' (+0.5 law points) 'But… I have something that I need to talk to you about, too' (+0.5 law points) and 'I need to think some more before I do, though' (+0.5 law points) for the maximum law response
(1.5 law points)
Reply 'You surprised me when you came over so suddenly' (no change) 'So, are you home alone right now?' (no change) then finally, 'Not that I'm implying anything…' (no change) for a neutral response.
Reply: 'Please don't come over without calling me beforehand.' (+0.5 chaos points) 'Is work really keeping you so busy?'(+1 chaos point) 'Ugh… That's not the way I meant it.' (no change) then 'I'm pretty tired, so I'll talk to you later.'(+0.5 chaos points)for the maximum chaos response (2 chaos points)
Reply to 'Some good medicine' from Catherine with:
Reply: 'I told you already! You can't keep doing this!' (+0.5 law points) and 'Please stop sending me these pictures.' (+0.5 law points) for the maximum law response. (1 law point)
Reply: 'This is crossing the line… '(no change) 'These pictures are going to make things really complicated for me' (no change) then 'Well, whatever… See ya.' (no change) for a neutral response.
Reply: 'Niiiiiiiice' (+1 chaos point), 'Have I ever mentioned my perfect 10' (+1 chaos point) then 'Don't go overboard, ok?' (+0.5 chaos points)for the maximum chaos response. (2.5 chaos points)
Talk to Lindsey and Martha and reply with 'Woof' for law points or 'Meow' for chaos points.
Reply to 'I'm wondering' from Catherine:
Reply: 'Does it matter?', (no change) 'I just can't see you today.' then 'I'll see you later' for a neutral/maximum law response.
Reply: 'I'm not lying!' (+1 chaos point) 'I've been really tired lately.' (no change) 'Come on, cheer up.' (+0.5 chaos points) 'I wish I could see you…' (+1 chaos point) then 'Good night, Catherine.' (+0.5 chaos points) for the maximum chaos response (2 chaos points)
If you answer positively then you will later receive another mail from Catherine entitled 'Oh...'
Talk to Lindsey and Martha again.
Sit down and talk to Daniel and Anna ('Love is patient, Love is kind' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to Justin whilst still sat down and select 'It's not your fault' selecting, 'What's done is done' may work for the achievement/trophy ('Read all about it!' Achievement/Trophy)
Stand up and talk to Daniel and Justin once more
Reply to Katherine's mail, 'Hey...'
Reply: 'Sorry, it's nothing' (+0.5 law points), 'Thanks for worrying about me' (+0.5 law points) and 'Good night, Katherine' (+0.5 law points) for the maximum law response (1.5 law points)
Reply: 'Sorry, I'm just tired...' (no change), ''Maybe it's because I'm drunk (no change), 'Well, good night' (no change) for a neutral response.
Reply: 'Does it matter?' (+0.5 chaos points), 'I have a lot on my mind, too.' (+0.5 chaos points) then 'I'm going to drink a little more here, so I'll talk to you later.' (+0.5 chaos points) for the maximum chaos response (1.5 chaos points)
Sit down and talk to Morgan, select 'If I have to choose, yes' ('One Last Case' Achievement/Trophy)
Reply to Catherine's mail 'Oh...' if you answered positively to 'I'm wondering'
Reply: 'You're starting to bug me' (+1 law point) then 'No matter what you say I still can't see you tonight' (+1 law point) and finally 'So that's it, see you' (no change) for the maximum law response (2 law points)
Reply:'I'm only trying to make sure...' then 'But I can't see you tonight' then 'Let's discuss this some other time, okay?' for the most neutral response (no change)
Reply:'I didn't say you were the bad guy' (+0.5 chaos points), 'In fact, I'm the bad guy' (no change) then 'I'm sorry if I made you mad.' (+0.5 chaos points), 'Come on, don't be mad.' (+0.5 chaos points), 'Absence makes the heart grow stronger, right?.' (+1 chaos point) then finally 'You don't need me tonight, stop causing trouble.' (+0.5 chaos points) for the maximum chaos response (3 chaos points)
If you reply with the maximum law response then you will receive a phone call from Catherine.
Talk to Toby, Jonny and Orlando
Talk to Erica twice
Talk to Boss twice
Watch television, talk to Boss until everybody else leaves
Stay in the bar when all the other patrons have left to unlock 'You don't have to go home...' which is worth 5G or a Bronze Trophy.
Night 6: Clock Tower.
Landing 1
Talk to all the sheep on the landing.
Talk to the sheep and select, 'I've been answering honestly...' ('Everyday Hero')
Talk to the sheep with glasses and select, 'Let's do it' ('Read all about it!' Achievement/Trophy)
Landing 2
Talk to all the sheep on the landing.
Talk to the sheep with the police hat and select, 'What kind of training?' ('One Last Case' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to the sheep with glasses and select, 'That's a lot!' ('Read all about it!' Achievement/Trophy)
Landing 3
Talk to all the sheep on the landing.
Talk to the long haired sheep and select, 'Come on, don't think like that.' ('Mother Inferior' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to the sheep with sunglasses and select, 'Join the meeting' ('Love is patient, Love is kind' Achievement/Trophy)
Talk to the sheep with the police hat and select, 'Are you really going to give up here' ('One Last Case' Achievement/Trophy)
Day 6: The Stray Sheep Bar.
Drinkall four alcoholic drinks; Cocktail, Beer, Whisky, Sake. (Cocktail Connoisseur, Beer Baron, Whisky Wiseman and Sake Sensei Achievements.)
Talk to Orlando twice
Talk to Jonny twice
Receive mail 'Congratulations'
Talk to Toby twice
Receive and answer the mail 'What's going on?' from Katherine.
Reply: 'Don't worry about it' (+0.5 law points), 'You don't have to worry about anything.' (+0.5 law points), 'Sorry, I'll explain everything to you when it's all over.' (+1 law point), then finally 'I love you, Katherine.' (+1 law point) for the maximum law response (3 law points)
Reply: 'You're worrying too much.' (no change) 'It was just a misunderstanding' (no change) 'I'm sorry you're worried about me' (+0.5 law points) then finally 'Bye' (+0.5 chaos points) for the most neutral response (no change)
Reply: 'You don't believe me?'(+0.5 chaos points) ,'Why are you telling me this?' (+1 chaos point), 'It's not a big deal (+0.5 chaos points), then 'Bye' (+0.5 chaos points) for the maximum chaos response (2.5 chaos points)
If you obtain at least 1.5 law points during this text then Katherine will answer with the mail 'Can I trust you?' later on.
Talk to Lindsey and Martha, answer with 'I hate politics' for law points or 'I hate economics' for chaos points.
Receive and answer the mail 'I'm so excited!' from Catherine
Reply: 'I told you to stop sending me pictures' (+0.5 law points) then 'I didn't mean to commit to anything this morning' (no change) for the maximum law response (+0.5 law points)
Reply: 'I.. uh.. still haven't decided if I go' (no change) then 'I didn't mean to commit to anything this morning' (no change) for the most neutral response (no change).
Reply: 'Is it... going to be a date?' (+0.5 chaos points) then 'Anyway, i'll see you tomorrow' (+1 chaos point) for the maximum chaos response (+1.5 chaos points)
Talk to Lindsey and Martha again
Talk to Anna at the bar twice
Receive and answer the mail 'Can I trust you?' from Katherine if you met the requirement earlier.
Reply: 'I'm really settled now, trust me' (no change) then, 'There's really nothing for you to worry about' (+0.5 law points), then 'You're the most important thing to me, always (+1 law point), then finally 'Thank you for worrying about me' (+0.5 law points) for the maximum law response (2 law points)
Reply:'I'm really settled now, trust me' (no change) then, 'I'm not going to cause you any trouble' (no change) then 'You can relax' (+0.5 law points), then finally 'Thanks for messaging me' (no change) for the most neutral response of (+0.5 law points)
Reply: 'Quit grilling me...' (+0.5 chaos points), 'Even if I told you you probably wouldn't understand' (+0.5 chaos points) then finally 'Hasn't this been enough? Good night.' (+0.5 chaos points) for the maximum chaos response of (1.5 chaos points)
If you respond with at least 1.5 law points to this text then you will receive a phone call from Katherine.
Talk to Justin and pick 'Is there a reason?' ('Read all about it!' Achievement/Trophy)
Receive mail 'The Rapunzel Puzzle'
Talk to Justin again
Talk to Orlando
Talk to Toby
Talk to Boss twice
Talk to Erica twice
Night 7: Spiral Corridor
Landing 1
Talk to everybody that's left.
When talking to the sheep with glasses pick 'Let's work together.'
Speak to the sheep with sunglasses and pick 'Don't give up, follow me!'
Landing 2
There are no dialogue options but you must talk to everybody here, especially the Long Haired Sheep, Sheep with Glasses, Sheep with Sunglasses, Sheep with Police Hat and the Sheep with Regent Hair
Landing 3
This is the last landing but again there's no dialogue options. Talk to everybody again, in particular the Long Haired Sheep, Sheep with Glasses, Sheep with Sunglasses, Sheep with Police Hat and the Sheep with Regent Hair
Day 7: The Stray Sheep Bar
Drink all four alcoholic drinks; Cocktail, Beer, Whisky, Sake. (Cocktail Connoisseur, Beer Baron, Whisky Wiseman and Sake Sensei Achievements.)Talk to the couple twiceTalk to Lindsey and Martha twice
Receive mail 'Congratulations'
Talk to Lindsey and Martha
Talk to Boss
Receive and answer mail 'Hey' from Katherine
Reply: 'Thanks for texting me' (+0.5 law points) then 'It makes me realize just how important you are to me...' (+1 law point) for the maximum law response (1.5 law points)
Reply: 'I guess we just missed each other' (no change) then 'I'm so sorry for everything...' (no change) for a neutral response (no change).
There is no reply for a chaos response so just reply with the neutral one, it will not affect a 'chaos' ending.
Talk to Boss twice
Talk to Erica twice
Receive mail 'The Experience Enigma'
Talk to Boss/Erica to advance time, finish up in the bar and save your game.
Day 8: The Stray Sheep Bar
Drink all of the alcoholic drinks to finally unlock the following four achievements/trophies: Cocktail Connoisseur, Beer Baron, Whisky Wiseman and Sake Sensei.
Talk to Daniel and Anna to unlock 'Love is Patient, Love is Kind'
Receive mail 'Attachment Issues' - depending on how many endings you've viewed, you can exit in and out of this mail for additional pictures.
Talk to Justin to unlock 'Read All About It'
Talk to Morgan to unlock 'One Last Case'
Talk to Toby twice
Talk to Orlando twice
Talk to Jonny twice
Talk to Erica
Talk to Todd and Archie for the achievements/trophies 'A New Look' and 'Mother Inferior'
Talk to Erica twice
You can leave now, or talk to everybody once more. Upon leaving the bar, provided you've replied to at least 20 texts during the game you should now unlock the 'Text Junkie' achievement/trophy.
Night 9: The Empireo
So, we're almost at the end of the game. Night 9 will be where you make the final decision on which of the 8 endings you'll end up seeing. Not all 8 will be available to be unlocked by this point in the game and it will depend on your Karma meter but you can see how to answer the questions during the landings of Night 9 to achieve the different endings by consulting the chart below. You can view details about the specific endings by clicking their links to a post about Catherine's storyline.
Bear in mind that the first question, "Are you prepared to risk your life to get back together with a former lover?" asked on Landing 9-1 has no bearing on the ending you receive, so answer it how you wish.
Stage 9-2 question: Do you wish for a peaceful life?
Stage 9-3 question: Do you wish for the excitement of chaos?
| Achievement | Ending | Karma Meter | Stage 9-2 Answer | Stage 9-3 Answer | Stage 9-4 Answer | |
 | Starting A New Life | Katherine True (True Lover Ending) | Max Law | Yes | No | Left |
 | Just Like Old Times | Katherine Good (Normal Lover Ending) | Mostly Law | Yes Yes No No | Yes No Yes No | Left Right Right Right, Left |
 | Nighty Night | Katherine Bad (Bad Lover Ending) | Mostly Chaos | Yes No No | Yes Yes No | Left Right Right, Left |
 | Lord of the Night | Catherine True (True Cheater Ending) | Max Chaos | No | Yes | Left |
 | Sleepless Nights | Catherine Good (Normal Cheater Ending) | Mostly Chaos | Yes Yes No No | Yes No Yes No | Right Right Right Right, Right |
 | Hit The Road, Vincent | Catherine Bad (Bad Cheater Ending) | Mostly Law | Yes No No | Yes Yes No | Right Left Right, Right |
 | Whatever, buddy | Freedom Good | Middle, partially law/chaos. | No | No | Yes, Left |
 | A Life Without Regrets | True Freedom | Middle Neutral | No | No | Yes, Left |
